The Executioner. Fortunately the store still had plenty of the blind bags left to squeeze upon my return, and I was easily able to ascertain which one contained Zorro by feeling for his hat and sword.
Still not sure if there's any sort of decipherable code for these guys, but the black printed numbers on the back of Zorro are as follows:
14811 0506 002167 5203 01
Which gives us the following codes so far:
Executioner: 14611 0784 008357 5203 01
Zorro: 14811 0506 002167 5203 01
Highwaywoman: 15311 0784 000845 5201 01